EDIT** I just noticed the last post of this was from 2012..Stupid me I'm sorry guys.
Okay I've downloaded both of them and have done some testing.. I'm also writing this as I am testing it. These tests were done with Ranger 1.1 and Ranger 3.04. Settings used were:
---------------------------------
Map: Arabia and Black Forest
Civ: Always Mayans for both
Size: All
Difficulty: Hard
Players: 1V1
Resources: Standard
Pop: 200
Reveal Map: All Visible
Starting Age: Standard
Victory: Conquest
1v1
Ranger 1.1 W:0 L1
Ranger 3.04 W1 L0 Arabia tiny
1v1
Ranger 1.1 W:0 L2
Ranger 3.04 W2 L0 Arabia small
1v1
Ranger 1.1 W:0 L3
Ranger 3.04 W3 L0 Arabia medium
1v1
Ranger 1.1 W:0 L4
Ranger 3.04 W4 L0 Arabia normal
1v1
Ranger 1.1 W:0 L5
Ranger 3.04 W5 L0 Arabia large
1v1
Ranger 1.1 W:0 L6
Ranger 3.04 W6 L0 Arabia giant
1v1
Ranger 1.1 W:0 L7
Ranger 3.04 W7 L0 Black Forest tiny
1v1
Ranger 1.1 W:0 L8
Ranger 3.04 W8 L0 Black Forest small
1v1
Ranger 1.1 W:0 L9
Ranger 3.04 W9 L0 Black Forest medium
1v1
Ranger 1.1 W:0 L9
Ranger 3.04 W9 L0 *DRAW* Black Forest normal
**-Now on this particular match Ranger 1 had somehow got all the relics and was fending off all of Ranger 3's attacks. As of now it's the 2 hour mark and I believe that's the (un)official game time. Ranger 1's score is 10,000 over Ranger 3's. Ranger 1 does not make use of his trebs at least in this match. And infact I don't think Ranger 3 even uses trebs! Ranger 1 has about 12 around his castle and they havn't even moved.. If I let this continue I believe Ranger 3 will end up winning by the looks of it.. and by the looks of it, it would probably be all day lol. But I'll say it's a draw!-**
1v1
Ranger 1.1 W:0 L10
Ranger 3.04 W10 L0 Black Forest large
1v1
Ranger 1.1 W:0 L10
Ranger 3.04 W10 L0 *DRAW* Black Forest huge
**-I've noticed that bottle necks do help Ranger 1 quite a bit in these black forest matches I also see Ranger 1 IS using his trebs in this match. Interesting.. Ranger 3 is also using trebs now.. It is now well past the 2 hour mark and they are caught up in a bottleneck all day fight here so it's another DRAW!-**
Final Score: Arabia Ranger 3.04 W-6 L-0 D-0 -- Ranger 1.1 W-0 L-6 D-0
Final Score Black Forest Ranger 3.04 W-4 L-0 D-2 -- Ranger 1.1 W-0 L-4 D-2
My Thoughts:
In one match tiny Arabia, Ranger 3's monk went right through Ranger 1's town in castle age and stole its relic right behind his town.. Pretty funny cause all the soldiers were busy fighting on the front right on Ranger 1 town and the relic was in the back left and he actually got it home leaving the town on the left side. :p That match was a win for Ranger 3 though.
Ranger 3 and Ranger 1 reaches feudal at about the same time.. It seems Ranger 1 goes for fast castle. By then feudal Ranger 3 has built up enough troops to annoy the hell out of castle Ranger 1 which reduces the economy time.. Which is essential. I also noticed that what I just said only applies to the smaller maps. The larger maps it seems Ranger 3 is getting to feudal and castle at roughly the same time. Also those towers Ranger 3 puts up close to Ranger 1's town is also a hindrance to Ranger 1's Eco.
I noticed as well that Ranger 1 hunts boar with 1 villager then garrisons in the TC then un-garrisons, hits the boar with an arrow, goes back into the TC and repeat until the boar is dead. Odd way of killing the boar instead of the other villagers coming in to kill it off quickly. In fact in many cases the boar would kill the single villager trying to kill it and end up just running back off to wherever.
I've noticed that with both Rangers, they do not build mining camps close to far away res.. They will travel long distances to mine far away res.
Ranger 3 is having a much harder time in the small black forest match. The bottle necks are helping Ranger 1 build up. But once Ranger 3's siege units arrive the bottle neck is gone and Ranger 3 opens up that can
Ranger 3 is more efficient at getting relics. (Most of the time)
I find it strange that when Ranger 3 is killing off Ranger 1's towns, he won't resign. No matter what.
Now on the giant maps it took Ranger 3 a lot longer to take down Ranger 1. Although with any size map Ranger 3's victories all happen within the 45-65min range for Arabia and 65-105min range for Black Forest. Most of the time that is. Those Black Forest bottle necks really do a number and once Ranger 1 gets to post imperial he's a monster.
Thanks for these awesome AI's UnfairestEel!
That's my testing for 1v1 Rangers

Maybe I'll test teams next... Cheers
